Artists
Sources
Dates
List Management
Help
Add Source
List Collectors
Add to Collection
I Was There
Add to Want List
Wanted By
History
Edit Show
Set I
Disc 1
A. Nightride (2/22/70)
70.01 Shepherd (4:00)
70.02 Pacidy (5:41)
70.03 Let Us Now Make Love (6:13)
70.04 Stagnation (8:03)
- much different than Trespass
70.05 Looking For Someone (7:18)
- alt lyrics and different ending
- quite different than Trespass version
*note: Dusk was also performed, but it's not circulating
*note2: I've got Stagnation from two sources - one
with applause dubbed in at the end and one without.
The recording without the dubbed applause is
inferior as it has more static and distortion.
I prefer the cleaner version with the dubbed
applause. Using SoundForge I've removed
the applause. It is now 8:03. Both tracks have
minor dropouts throughout.
From the Genesis Discography:
"Some releases of these songs have audience
applause dubbed into the mix -- this is not in
the original. These are studio recordings."
B. Sounds Of The Seventies (5/10/71)
71.01 The Musical Box (11:54)
- substantial lyric variation
71.02 Stagnation (8:52)
- closer to Trespass version
C. Sounds Of The Seventies (1/9/72)
72a.01 Harold The Barrel (3:01)
- longer ending; more piano notes than on LP version (3:00)
72a.02 Harlequin (2:37)
- full ending, not fade-out guitar notes as on LP (2:56)
72a.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed (7:31)
- cut-off a second or two early
- faster, shorter than LP version (8:10)
- drums barely audible, less instrumentation?
*note: Fountain Of Salmacis was also
part of this but it's not circulating
*note2: These are the lowest quality recordings
of the BBC tapes.
A. Nightride (2/22/70)
70.01 Shepherd (4:00)
70.02 Pacidy (5:41)
70.03 Let Us Now Make Love (6:13)
70.04 Stagnation (8:03)
- much different than Trespass
70.05 Looking For Someone (7:18)
- alt lyrics and different ending
- quite different than Trespass version
*note: Dusk was also performed, but it's not circulating
*note2: I've got Stagnation from two sources - one
with applause dubbed in at the end and one without.
The recording without the dubbed applause is
inferior as it has more static and distortion.
I prefer the cleaner version with the dubbed
applause. Using SoundForge I've removed
the applause. It is now 8:03. Both tracks have
minor dropouts throughout.
From the Genesis Discography:
"Some releases of these songs have audience
applause dubbed into the mix -- this is not in
the original. These are studio recordings."
B. Sounds Of The Seventies (5/10/71)
71.01 The Musical Box (11:54)
- substantial lyric variation
71.02 Stagnation (8:52)
- closer to Trespass version
C. Sounds Of The Seventies (1/9/72)
72a.01 Harold The Barrel (3:01)
- longer ending; more piano notes than on LP version (3:00)
72a.02 Harlequin (2:37)
- full ending, not fade-out guitar notes as on LP (2:56)
72a.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed (7:31)
- cut-off a second or two early
- faster, shorter than LP version (8:10)
- drums barely audible, less instrumentation?
*note: Fountain Of Salmacis was also
part of this but it's not circulating
*note2: These are the lowest quality recordings
of the BBC tapes.
Set II
Disc 2
D. In Concert (3/2/72)
72b.01 Fountain Of Salmacis (10:07)
72b.02 The Musical Box (10:57)
72b.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed (7:44)
*note: These sound particularly great
E. Sounds Of The Seventies (9/25/72)
72c.01 Twilight Alehouse (8:08)
72c.02 Watcher of The Skies (7:47)
72c.03 Get 'em Out By Friday (8:51)
*note: Also very good SQ
___________________
Sources of tracks
A. Nightride (2/22/70)
70.01 Shepherd
70.02 Pacidy
70.03 Let Us Now Make Love
from Genesis Archives 1967-75
70.04 Stagnation
trade from Luis G
70.05 Looking For Someone
from From One Fan To All Others
B. Sounds Of The Seventies (5/10/71)
71.01 The Musical Box
71.02 Stagnation
from From One Fan To All Others
C. Sounds Of The Seventies (1/9/72)
72a.01 Harold The Barrel
72a.02 Harlequin
from Luis G - radio broadcast
72a.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed
trade from Willem B - radio broadcast
D. In Concert (3/2/72)
72b.01 Fountain Of Salmacis
72b.02 The Musical Box
72b.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed
from DAT transfer from the BBC master, according to Luis
E. Sounds Of The Seventies (9/25/72)
72c.01 Twilight Alehouse
72c.02 Watcher of The Skies
72c.03 Get 'em Out By Friday
from DAT transfer from the BBC master, according to Luis
D. In Concert (3/2/72)
72b.01 Fountain Of Salmacis (10:07)
72b.02 The Musical Box (10:57)
72b.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed (7:44)
*note: These sound particularly great
E. Sounds Of The Seventies (9/25/72)
72c.01 Twilight Alehouse (8:08)
72c.02 Watcher of The Skies (7:47)
72c.03 Get 'em Out By Friday (8:51)
*note: Also very good SQ
___________________
Sources of tracks
A. Nightride (2/22/70)
70.01 Shepherd
70.02 Pacidy
70.03 Let Us Now Make Love
from Genesis Archives 1967-75
70.04 Stagnation
trade from Luis G
70.05 Looking For Someone
from From One Fan To All Others
B. Sounds Of The Seventies (5/10/71)
71.01 The Musical Box
71.02 Stagnation
from From One Fan To All Others
C. Sounds Of The Seventies (1/9/72)
72a.01 Harold The Barrel
72a.02 Harlequin
from Luis G - radio broadcast
72a.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed
trade from Willem B - radio broadcast
D. In Concert (3/2/72)
72b.01 Fountain Of Salmacis
72b.02 The Musical Box
72b.03 The Return Of The Giant Hogweed
from DAT transfer from the BBC master, according to Luis
E. Sounds Of The Seventies (9/25/72)
72c.01 Twilight Alehouse
72c.02 Watcher of The Skies
72c.03 Get 'em Out By Friday
from DAT transfer from the BBC master, according to Luis
Set III
Comment
Click 'Edit Show' or the 'Set I(II)(III)' or 'Comment' text to make corrections.
If this is a duplicate or incorrect entry and should be merged, use the Request Merge page.
If this is a duplicate or incorrect entry and should be merged, use the Request Merge page.
Collectors With This Show
| User (active/rating) | Media / # | Show | Sound | Details | DB Source | User Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Waz (5/5) | Shn / 1 | A | A- | View | BBC Studio sessions. | |
| Notes: | SBD. | |||||
| gb bertoni (4/4.5) | CDR / 2 | View | BBC recordings 1970-1972 | |||
| Bill d'Angelo (3/5) | CDR/Flac / 2 | View | FM | |||
| rkipp (3/0) | / 0 | A | View | FM | ||
| Bluesthinker (2/4.9) | CDR / 2 | View | ||||
| phil (1/5) | flac / 0 | a | View | pre-fm>flac | ||
| LossLess Legs (1/0) | CDR / 2 | View | Studio | |||
| Notes: | 12/30/2008 - CDJones | |||||
| Phil (1/5) | FLAC/DVD / 1 | View | ||||
| Notes: | On FLAC/DVD: Genesis The Complete BBC Sessions 1970-1972 9-13-82 1-3-09 Derek Trucks - 9-11-08 George Thorogood - 11-23-77 Gregg Allman - 12-27-93 Planet Earth Rock and Roll Orchestra - Jan. 1971- Perro Sessions Wake of the Dead - 11-14-01 Procol Harum - The Elusive Procol Harum | |||||
| Cheryl (1/0) | shn / 1 | View | FM | |||
| Neil (1/0) | / 0 | View | ||||
| graziano1 (1/0) | / 0 | View | ||||
| Eddy (1/3.9) | 1cdr / 0 | A- | View | BBC Radio | ||
| Notes: | BBC radio "From one fan" | |||||
| hackett732 (1/0) | CD / 1 | A | View | |||
| Notes: | "BBC Sessions 1970-1972" | |||||